Large Desserts

Peanut Butter Cream Pie

4.2 / 5 (24)

100% recommend this product.

Enjoy this sweet treat made with real peanut butter and a chocolate cookie-crumb crust, whipped topping, and chocolate curls.

Where to Buy Nutrition Information

Customer Reviews

Arrange By:
  • so close to perfection!

    I couldn't be more impressed with how close this tastes to my homemade one. This must be new in Ohio as I haven't seen before in the freezer section at Krogers. A+ everyone loves. Just be sure to wait until completely thawed to eat. If not, it tastes too much like icecream and you lose the creaminess part of it.

    EJMGAL in Columbus, OH

  • Better than home made

    This pie was better than home made without the mess. Very good and creamy!

    Sue in Pennsylvania

  • Peanut Butter perfection!

    Marie Callender's peanut butter pie is not just one of the best pies I've ever eaten... it is definitely the best frozen pie that you can buy. if you served this to someone without telling them that it was store bought and frozen they would think you had made it. The peanut butter filling is perfect and the crust is perfect too. If you are a fan of peanut butter you owe it to yourself to try this pie!

    KoTo in Christiansburg, VA

  • Dear Peanut Butter Pie..Where o where art thou???

    this is one GREAT pie...honestly, just like homemade, much better than anything Mrs Edwards, hands down, no comparison really..... only thing is, now that I LUST for them, I can't find them ANYWHERE in the Salisbury NC area...and that makes me sad!!!.....Please Please fill our retailers' freezers full....or, even better, just fill MY freezer full....I'll Let ya!!!

    shanimal in Rockwell, NC

  • Your Peanut Butter Pie!

    Has been my favorite since I was a child and I'm now 58. When you stopped having it in the local restaurants I thought I couldn't go on living. It was my dad's favorite as well, God rest his soul. He passed on and never had to experience not being able to order it after a Marie Callender's meal. And now I discover you have started producing them for stores. Only one problem... THE PIES AREN'T SOLD IN STORES NEAR ME! Thanks again MC!

    Gary B. in Irvine, California

  • Holiday Happy!

    First time purchase of a Marie Callender product - MADE MY THANKSGIVING! Thank you for the pleasant surprise!

    DeeDee in Glenolden, PA

Write a Review

Overall Rating

Would you recommend this product to a friend?


Writing Guidelines

  • Keep your review focused on the food
  • Avoid writing about customer service; contact us instead if you have issues requiring immediate attention
  • Refrain from mentioning competitors or the specific price you paid for the product
  • Do not include any personally identifiable information, such as full names

For privacy reasons, do not use your full name or email address.

Example: New York, NY

We will ONLY use your email address to notify you in regard to your submission.

Success! Your Review Has Been Submitted.

Please note that your review may take up to 48 hours to appear.

Back to Reviews
Peanut Butter Cream Pie