We make this pie with real peanut butter.
1278110271

Cream Pies

Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Savor this rich and creamy treat made with real peanut butter and a made-from-scratch chocolate cookie crumb crust. It's generously garnished with whipped topping and semi-sweet chocolate curls.

Nutrition Information Where to Buy

Average Rating:

4.3 / 5
85% recommend this product.
Write a Review

16 reviews for this product

Sort by:

Holiday Happy!

First time purchase of a Marie Callender product - MADE MY THANKSGIVING! Thank you for the pleasant surprise!

DeeDee

like it very much

This pie was a big sucess at our pot luck. I was so happy and will be buying this pie again and again.

Terry Sue

Absolutely Delicious

I love peanut butter and I love this pie! My roommate had a taste of the last piece I had (call me horrible but with this pie I was too selfish to give her more than a bite ;) and she had to go out and buy her own pie she loved it so much!

Sugarcookiencream

great!

delicious pie, our only problem was the whipped topping melted. It would be perfect to eat right after it thawed tho. I will definitely buy again.

fan of marie

Dear Peanut Butter Pie..Where o where art thou???

this is one GREAT pie...honestly, just like homemade, much better than anything Mrs Edwards, hands down, no comparison really..... only thing is, now that I LUST for them, I can't find them ANYWHERE in the Salisbury NC area...and that makes me sad!!!.....Please Please fill our retailers' freezers full....or, even better, just fill MY freezer full....I'll Let ya!!!

shanimal

Please Stock This Peanut Butter Cream Pie

I saw this pie in the store, bought the last two for my Dad, and haven't been able to find them anywhere else since then. This is his very favorite pie, and by far better than even those you can buy in a bakery or pie store. Please keep them coming to more store who sell your Marie Callender Pies!!!

LizK

A-MAZING!!!!

This pie is so amazingly delicious that I might have to keep myself from buying more but I may refuse not too as it just tastes so dang good. If you haven't tried this pie yet please go to your nearest grocery store and find one. Enjoy the pie people :D.

ILikePeanutButter

Hard to get before sold out...

You know, there's only ever one left when I go shopping every week and my store keeps buying more. I'm not sure why Im leaving this review because it'll probably cause less to be available. I guess I feel Marie Calenders deserves recognition for this seemingly perfect pie. I consider myself a connoisseur of deserts and this one really is something special. I couldn't believe how good it was the first time I tried it. It's now my favorite desert and Im talking compared to homemade, restaurant, professional chefs...none of them rival this pie. It's award winning. Good luck trying to outdo yourself on this one Marie Calenders.

Jordy

Your Peanut Butter Pie!

Has been my favorite since I was a child and I'm now 58. When you stopped having it in the local restaurants I thought I couldn't go on living. It was my dad's favorite as well, God rest his soul. He passed on and never had to experience not being able to order it after a Marie Callender's meal. And now I discover you have started producing them for stores. Only one problem... THE PIES AREN'T SOLD IN STORES NEAR ME! Thanks again MC!

Gary B.

Your Peanut Butter Pie!

Has been my favorite since I was a child and I'm now 58. When you stopped having it in the local restaurants I thought I couldn't go on living. It was my dad's favorite as well, God rest his soul. He passed on and never had to experience not being able to order it after a Marie Callender's meal. And now I discover you have started producing them for stores. Only one problem... THE PIES AREN'T SOLD IN STORES NEAR ME! Thanks again MC!

Gary B.

Load More Reviews
Loading...
Marie Callender's: 1278110271
From my kitchen to yours since 1948.